Free for churches using Planning Center

See how your songs speak: about God, or to God.

Score every worship song in Planning Center Services from 1 (sung about God, for the edification of the church) to 5 (sung to God). The scores become tags you can filter, report on, and use to plan services with both declaration and prayer.

Mac and Windows · No coding · Practice mode included · Open source (MIT)

To download, open this project's GitHub page, click the green Code button, and choose Download ZIP.

← About GodTo God →
1
HorizontalDeclaration, teaching, testimony, calls to worship
2
Mostly HorizontalMostly declaration, with a moment of prayer
3
BlendVerses about God, a chorus to Him, equal weight
4
Mostly VerticalMostly prayer or praise, with some declaration
5
VerticalPrayer, praise, and surrender addressed to God
Why score your songs?

For God's Glory and our Good

When the church sings, we sing to God, bringing Glory to His name, and in doing so we sing for the benefit of each other. Congregational worship does both.

5

Vertical

Sung to God

Songs and expressions that ascribe worth to God. Their direction is upward, and they're often a response to the revelation of Jesus. These songs echo what heaven is already doing.

For example: Holy, Holy, Holy · Great Are You, Lord · Holy Forever

1

Horizontal

Sung about God, edifying one another

Songs about God, His Word, and His works. They're declarative: they proclaim truth and doctrine, and they edify the body as we sing that truth together.

For example: Christ Our Hope in Life and Death · Is He Worthy?

“Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly, teaching and admonishing one another in all wisdom, singing psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, with thankfulness in your hearts to God.”
Colossians 3:16 (ESV)

In one sentence, Paul tells the church to teach one another (horizontal) by singing to God (vertical). It's the same act, moving in both directions.

Which should we choose? Both.

The right balance isn't always the middle. When the moment calls for ascribing glory to God, we lean vertical. When the body needs to be reminded of eternal truth, we lean horizontal.

Either way, singing together is never only personal. Scripture says we address one another as we sing to the Lord (Ephesians 5:19–21), and that everything we do when we gather is for edifying one another (1 Corinthians 14:26). Greg Gilbert of 9Marks applies this to singing: sing even the songs that aren't your favorites, and sing them wholeheartedly, because someone beside you may be deeply strengthened by them. That's true whether you're on a microphone, holding a guitar, or running slides from the back.

From revelation to response

Worship often moves from revelation to response. Many churches shape a service to retell the gospel, and that flow tends to move from horizontal toward vertical:

  1. God Who He is: His nature and attributes
  2. Us Our sin, our condition, and our need
  3. Christ His atoning work: our assurance and salvation
  4. Response How we answer all of it
← HorizontalVertical →

Where scoring helps

A score doesn't rank a song. A 1 isn't better or worse than a 5. It simply names the song's direction, so your team can:

  • plan a service's flow from revelation to response on purpose, not by feel alone
  • notice when a season, a series, or your most-used songs lean heavily one way
  • filter and report on it in Planning Center, because the scores are ordinary song tags
  • talk about songs with shared language across musicians, tech, and leadership

Planning tools have their limits. Whatever we do, in word or deed, we do in the name of the Lord Jesus, giving thanks to the Father through Him (Colossians 3:17). Good intentions and careful planning don't make our worship acceptable; as Harold Best reminds us, only God, seeing faithfully offered work as perfect in Christ, does that.

Further reading: Harold M. Best, Unceasing Worship · Greg Gilbert on congregational singing at 9Marks

How it works

Four steps, all from one simple menu.

Double-click Start Tagger, pick a number, and follow the prompts. If you can fill in a spreadsheet, you can do this.

1

Set up once

Create five score tags in Planning Center and connect the tool with a key. Its instructions walk you through it.

About 30 min, once
2

Make a scoring sheet

Export your songs from Planning Center. The tool turns the export into a simple spreadsheet, for every song or just the lists you choose.

5 min
3

Score each song

Type a 1–5 next to each song using the one-page rubric, or let Claude score them and review only the ones it's unsure about.

30 min – 2 hrs
4

Send to Planning Center

The tool sends 3 songs first so you can check them, then sends the rest. Every other tag on each song is kept.

About 10 min
Ways to score

Score the songs yourself, or have Claude help.

Every path uses the same rubric and the same tool to send scores to Planning Center. Choose the one that fits your team.

No AI needed

Score it yourself

Open the scoring sheet in Excel, Numbers, or Google Sheets, keep the printed rubric next to you, and type a number for each song.

  • Good for teams who want to talk through every song
  • Easy to split among several people
Printable rubric (PDF)
For Cowork users

Claude Cowork skill

Install the skill and ask Claude to "score my scoring sheet." It reads the files directly and fills in the sheet for you.

  • Remembers your house rules between sessions
  • Walks the admin through each menu step
Download the skill
Built to be safe

Your library stays intact.

What the tool does

  • Changes only the 1–5 score tag on each song. Lists, themes, seasons, and every other tag are kept.
  • Sends 3 songs first and waits until you've checked them in Planning Center.
  • Is safe to run again: songs that already have the right score are skipped.
  • Keeps a record of every song it sends in a log file.
  • Includes a practice mode with made-up songs that changes nothing.

What stays with you

  • Your Planning Center key is saved only on your computer, and you can turn it off anytime in Planning Center.
  • Song exports and lyrics stay on your computer and are never included in the project files.
  • Claude reads lyrics only to choose a score and is instructed never to reproduce them.
  • The code is open source, so anyone can read exactly what it does.
What you'll need

Probably everything you already have.

A Planning Center login

One that can edit songs in Services.

A Mac or Windows PC

Plus Python, a free program. The guide shows how to install it.

A spreadsheet app

Excel, Numbers, or Google Sheets.

Claude (optional)

Only if you want Claude to do the scoring.

Resources

Everything in one place.

Questions

Frequently asked

Is a vertical song better than a horizontal one?

No. Both directions are biblical, and healthy corporate worship needs both. The score describes a song's direction, not its quality or its worth. A church may lean one way for a season, and that's fine. The point is to choose on purpose.

Do I need to know how to code?

No. You double-click a file, choose numbers from a menu, and fill in a spreadsheet. The Admin Guide is written for office admins and volunteers, and covers installing Python (a free program the tool needs) on Mac and Windows.

Will it change anything else in Planning Center?

No. It changes only the 1–5 score tag on each song and keeps every other tag. It also sends 3 songs first so you can check them before it does the rest.

Do I need Claude or any other AI?

No. You can score every song yourself with the printed rubric. Claude is optional and makes the job faster: it scores the list and flags only the songs it's unsure about for you to review.

What does it cost?

The tool is free and open source. You need a Planning Center Services account that can edit songs. If you choose to use Claude, the usual Claude plan applies.

What happens to our song lyrics?

Lyrics come from your own Planning Center export and stay on your computer. They're shared with Claude only if you choose that route, and Claude is instructed to use them only to choose a score, never to reproduce them. The project files never include any lyrics.

Can we use different labels or a different scale?

Yes. Planning Center's tag names can say anything as long as each starts with its number, 1 through 5. You can also adapt the rubric to your context. Just make sure everyone on your team uses the same one.

What about songs we add later?

Export again and choose to leave out songs that already have a score. Your new scoring sheet will include only the new songs.

Is this made by Planning Center?

No. It's an independent tool built by a church worship team and shared for others to use. It uses Planning Center's official API.

Ready to try it?

Start with the practice mode. It runs the whole process with made-up songs and changes nothing in Planning Center.